Circle vs Mighty (2025 Comparison): Which Platform Is Right for Your Community?
- Brianna Leever
- 7 days ago
- 3 min read
Updated: 1 day ago
This article is routinely updated as new features are rolled out. Last updated October 2025.
TL;DR
If you’re deciding between Circle and Mighty Networks for your online community, here’s the short version:
Circle wins for communities with any combination of education and connection, clean UX, and scalable customization.
Mighty Networks may be a good option for cohort-based communities or high ticket communities, it offers a high degree of support for the admin, and an improved UX.
Circle prioritizes member experience. Mighty prioritizes admin convenience.
👉 The choice comes down to whether you want a community that’s easy to join or a platform that’s easier for you to manage.
Introduction
Circle and Mighty Networks are two of the biggest names in community platforms, and two of the most debated in my client calls. So let’s get real about which one’s riding the marketing hype, and which one actually makes your members stick around.
Prefer to watch instead? Watch the full Circle vs Mighty Networks breakdown on YouTube →
Here’s how they compare:
Circle vs Mighty: Which Platform Wins in 2025?
After building 40+ communities on Circle and supporting several migrations from Mighty, my final take is this:
Choose Circle if your community thrives on engagement, discussion, and connection.Â
Choose Mighty if you manage multiple smaller groups or high-ticket programs.
Final Thoughts
The truth is, the best community platform is the one that your members actually enjoy using. Circle and Mighty Networks both have their strengths, but what matters most is how you structure, onboard, and sustain the experience inside.
If you’re building your first community (or thinking about migrating) make sure to grab the full Platform Comparison Guide below. It includes:
FAQ
1. Is Circle better than Mighty Networks in 2025? Yes, for most models of community, Circle offers a cleaner UX, better engagement flow, and more customization and features.
2. When should I choose Mighty Networks instead of Circle? If your setup involves segmented cohorts, subgroups, or smaller high-ticket programs, Mighty can still be effective.
3. Does Circle have built-in AI tools? Yes. Circle’s AI focuses on improving member experience by surfacing relevant discussions and content.
4. Does Mighty Networks integrate better with other tools? Generally yes — Mighty offers more native integrations, while Circle relies more on API or Zapier.
5. Which platform is more expensive long-term? Circle’s packages and add-ons can stack up, but Mighty’s limited coupon and pricing flexibility can also drive up admin time and costs.
6. What’s the biggest UX difference between Circle and Mighty? Circle’s interface keeps everything visible in one sidebar. Mighty hides key discussions behind sub-menus, which can confuse new members.
First time building a community?
Check out our free Masterclass on the 4 Types of Communities to learn just how powerful a community can be for your business (and what to watch out for, too!)
COMING UP: Beyond the Comparison: Learn from Real Builders
This comparison is one piece of our broader Community Platform Comparison Series.
Join us for a live panel where community builders hosting their communities on Circle, Skool, Mighty, Kajabi, and Heartbeat share their perspectives on their experience building on each platform.
Join the Ember Community
The place for go-getter community entrepreneurs building community-powered businesses.